When I calculate how much I give to charities and donations, I feel downright miserly. And maybe I am.
Meg of World of Wealth is a blogger whom I have read for a long time. Though I don’t agree with all of her positions, she seems to be very smart and is certainly well-written, and I think she always adds an interesting perspective to the mix. She left this comment on my Personal Finance Confessions post:
I don’t want to be judgemental, but for somebody who is saving and earning as much as you, I’m a little bit shocked that you say you are trying to “work up” to giving $1000 a year. There’s no working about it – you can easily afford to give but choose not to.
My first reaction was to feel defensive (I donate my time! I help out people I know! I don’t have a trust fund!).
But after a few seconds I decided to reflect on that comment, because, Meg is right. I can afford to give $1,000 a year (or the equivalent of 10% of my income for 2010 edit: sorry, my math was completely off! $1,000 is around 4-5% of my net income for 2010, I was freelancing/unemployed for part of the year), but I don’t.
If I believe personal finance is about choices (which I do), then the reason why I don’t give is because I choose not to. For right or wrong, in accordance to or apart from my belief that I am a reasonably compassionate person, I have decided that other goals and items are a higher priority right now.
I choose to max out my 401K than donate that money.
I choose to buy nice clothes from Banana Republic than donate that money.
I choose to save for Galapagos than donate that money.
I choose to eat really expensive wild Atlantic salmon than donate that money.
These are choices that I’ve made, and I don’t think I like what that says about me.
Let me tell you, there’s nothing like a little blogosphere-induced self-reflection to make one feel mightily uncomfortable. (But that’s why I love it, you guys make me think).





