Today I had my first class with my tutor (whom I shall call Madam Instructor) for Mandarin class. I was pretty happy with how the session went and pleasantly surprised that I retained more comprehension than I thought I would.
Madam Instructor gave me a text that focuses on professional Mandarin – after we finish this text, she said, I should be able to read newspapers, business articles, and op-eds without any trouble. I am eagerly awaiting that day! Must use that for motivation as I begin the painful process of memorizing characters…
A few readers were surprised at the expense ($67 per hour – ouch. It hurt a little to write that). I chose private tutoring to get the best results within a short period of time. Even though private tutoring is expensive, I think the one-on-one attention and individualized curriculum are worth it.
MoneyMateKate commented in my previous post,
Here in NYC, state certified teachers make on average $50-60/hr for private tutoring. If your tutor isn’t a fully trained language teacher (as a former EFL teacher, I promise you, the methodology is different) and simply an expert because it’s her native tongue, you are paying about 3x what she’s worth. I’ve used both kinds of private tutors, and the difference is enormous.
I definitely agree that Madam Instructor is much more expensive than many other tutors. On Craigslist, I can find Mandarin tutors for as low as $15 / hour, and many more at $35-$50 per hour. I can, of course, also enroll in group classes at a much lower rate. But I went with Madam Instructor because of her experience teaching professional Mandarin (and because she was the most responsive to my inquiry). At the end of the day, I know her fee is high. But I don’t know if it’s too high. I hope not.
If I had unlimited funds, I would take private lessons in Spanish and Argentine tango. Hmm… maybe I can spend a few months in Buenos Aires, where I can learn Spanish during the day and dance tango at night! Mandarin was a more easily justified expenses because 1. It’s a professionally useful language, and 2. I already have a background in the language, so with some effort and time I can make a lot of progress.
Have you taken private lessons? Do you make a distinction between professionally-useful skills such as languages or golf versus purely recreational hobbies such as sculpture, dance, skiing, etc.?