What Should a Personal Finance College Class Look Like?

The lack of financial literacy among young people is a perenially hot topic. Who is responsible for teaching young adults the basics of earning, saving, and investing their money?

personal finance school class1 What Should a Personal Finance College Class Look Like?

Some colleges are taking up the challenge. My cousin, who attends one of the Seven Sisters, told me that her school offers a week-long personal finance class during Spring Break. (Huzzah!). So instead of flying home, she is going to stay on campus and attend the class instead. I was so excited to hear this – personal finance is a sorely needed subject, but most colleges don’t cover this at all. I received an excellent education from my school and took several semesters of accounting, macro-economics, and micro-economics. When I graduated college, however, I knew NOTHING about credit card rates, basics of asset allocation for personal investing, where to set up my cash accounts, etc. And let’s be honest, not everyone has to learn about the Argentine peso crisis, but everyone needs to understand how to manage their own money.

Fortunately, I fell into the world of personal finance blogging. So my deer-in-the-headlights period wasn’t as long as it could have been. Still, it would have been helpful to have a personal finance class before graduation, as part of a comprehensive education to launch young adults into the real world. I’ve discussed in the past whether schools have a responsibility to teach money management to students, so I’m glad that my cousin’s school is taking proactive steps to address this issue.

So, what SHOULD be in a week-long personal finance class? Here are my suggestions:

  • Setting up a budget and understanding real-life expenses. Or, a discussion of where does your gross pay actually goes to before you are left with your net paycheck, and then your discretionary income. Making $60,000 or doesn’t mean you HAVE $60,000 to spend. Sounds like a simple concept, but the first time I got my paycheck, I was shocked at the big discrepancy between my gross salary and my net income. I believe my reaction was along the lines of “Who is this FICA and WHY is he taking my money?”
  • How to pay for car / transportation. This should include discussion of car loans, down payments, auto insurance, etc.
  • How to handle student loans and possibly, prepare for graduate school financially. The class should talk about under what conditions can student loans be discharged (almost none), how long it will take you to pay off a student loan if you stay on a 10-year, 20-year, or 30-year payment plan, talk about the different types of student loan payment plans available and discuss the pros & cons of each, and map out what is the income you will need to earn to service your debts.
  • How to use credit effectively and responsibly. Over the course of a lifetime, those with an established, strong credit history save tens of thousands of dollars thanks to lower interest rates on everything from a mortgage to car financing to private student loans. So no discussion of personal finance can be complete without talking about credit. I am a big believer that credit cards can (and should) be a part of one’s financial tool kit. I’d like to see a discussion on credit card interest rates, impact of minimum payments and effective interest paid, how to manage your credit score, where to get your free credit reports, etc.
  • Investing for long-term goals and retirement (a thorough discussions of 401Ks / 403bs, Roth IRAs, IRAs, and SEP-IRAs, etc. would be very important here). Also, there should be a conversation on risk, rewards, fees, and impact on performance.
  • Insurance needs – talk about disability insurance, life insurance, types of insurance and places to do more research.
  • Teach them why personal finance is sexy. Seriously! What can be better than taking charge of your own financial life?
  • Where to go if you need more information or help about personal finances. Books, nonprofit classes, etc.

What do you think should be included in a personal finance class for college students? Would you have found such a class helpful when you were going to school?

What PF Bloggers Talk About

An exchange between me and Revanche of A Gai Shan Life
me: oh and happy daily savings
revanche: huh?
me: daylight savings
hahaahha
oh man
revanche: HAHHAHA
I thought you were just going off the PF deep end

The Traps of Mental Accounting: Why We Treat Money From Different Sources Differently

Do you practice mental accounting?

Most people do. Do you treat $1,000 that you receive as part of your regular salary differently than the same amount from a bonus or a winning lottery ticket? Research says yes, we do treat money differently, even though we shouldn’t.

We are more apt to splurge (on expensive purchases or vacations) with a gift or bonus of $1,000, but we are often more conservative with the same $1,000 that is deposited as part of our regular payment. But why should that be? $1,000 is $1,000 regardless of where they come from.

What is mental accounting?

According to Investopedia:

Mental accounting refers to the tendency for people to separate their money into separate accounts based on a variety of subjective criteria, like the source of the money and intent for each account. According to the theory, individuals assign different functions to each asset group, which has an often irrational and detrimental effect on their consumption decisions and other behaviors.

Different Source, Different Purpose

Another aspect of mental accounting is that people also treat money differently depending on its source. For example, people tend to spend a lot more “found” money, such as tax returns and work bonuses and gifts, compared to a similar amount of money that is normally expected, such as from their paychecks. This represents another instance of how mental accounting can cause illogical use of money.

Logically speaking, money should be interchangeable, regardless of its origin. Treating money differently because it comes from a different source violates that logical premise. Where the money came from should not be a factor in how much of it you spend – regardless of the money’s source, spending it will represent a drop in your overall wealth.

Me vs. mental accounting

I understand this concept intellectually, and yet I STILL fall prey to the traps of mental accounting. Exhibit A: for the past year or so I have ramped up my freelance efforts because I enjoy it, and it never hurts to have extra cash.

I also have noticed, however, that I am much more lenient with my freelance earnings and bonuses than I am with my salary. The salary is for 401K contributions, it’s for rent, it’s for gas and car repairs. In fact, I am quite a tightwad with my regular paychecks.

Yet something in my brain tells me that I should treat my freelance earnings and bonuses differently – that those dollars are for splurging on new clothes, or nice dinners, or massages. I spend much more frivolously when I think I am spending my “extra” money. But the truth is there is no such thing as “extra” money. ALL the money I have, including any gift money I’ve been lucky enough to receive, is interchangeable, they are all part of my net worth. A dollar that I have received as a part of a bonus is still a dollar, it’s not any different than a dollar I have earned as part of my regular paycheck.

Fighting against mental accounting

I am working hard to change my mental accounting tendencies. Part of that effort is the setting up of the SEP IRA – putting money away means that I won’t be tempted to spend it all on frivolous pursuits.

In addition, I’ve started to put a significant portion of my freelance dollars toward the Galapagos Fund. The money will still be spent, but it will be for a big once-in-a-lifetime trip that I will remember and cherish forever, instead of for small purchases that I will forget a week later.

Also, with every freelance paycheck I get I contribute to my estimated tax fund. This minimizes the free cash that’s lying in my checking account (less spending!) and will help me avoid an unpleasant surprise when April 2012 comes around.

Mental accounting might have gotten the best of me for a while, but I am fighting back!

Do you do mental accounting? How do you stop yourself?

photo via pksoni.com

Saving for Retirement: Love It? Hate It?

Growing up, I never had personal finance as part of the curriculum. But everything I’ve learned about motivation to save for retirement, I’ve learned in high school.

Recently, TeacHer Finance wrote a post sharing her perspective – she hates saving for retirement.  I understand her reasons.. maybe that’s why I don’t really think about them – because I am afraid of mentally discouraging myself from saving!  It is difficult to balance retirement with shorter-term goals, that is for sure.  And although there are good, logical reasons to save for retirement, the motivation factor, like I mentioned at the beginning of this post, was completely from high school.

From High School to Retirement Saving

This might be a nerdy way to explain it, but here is it. When I was in high school, I’d often slack off a little at the beginning of the semester – I wouldn’t study as hard as I should have, or prepare for the occasional pop quizzes that I KNOW will come up in class.  It’ll be okay, I told myself, I will work harder for the next test, the next presentation, the next project.

Towards the second half or 2/3 of the semester, I’d look at my class progress reports, feel disappointed, and then I’d hunker down and put my nose to the grindstone. But the simple mathematical truth was that for every 80% I got in the first half of the class, I’d have to get a 100% to achieve the 90% ending score I wanted. Let’s just say that it was a rare day that I got those 100%s.

And every time before the final, when it’s 4 AM in the morning and I am still pouring over my notes on European history or statistics or macroeconomics, stressed out of my mind, I think, why didn’t I start preparing earlier? If I had JUST prepared a little more at the beginning of the term, I wouldn’t have to work so hard towards the end, I would give myself more wiggle room, and I would probably have gotten a better grade.

The lesson I learned? Put the work in early, get better results for less effort.

That’s the thought process I bring to retirement saving. I am saving as much as I can right now so that I wouldn’t have to panic and start saving 30% of my income when I’m in my 30s or 40s, when I will surely have more financial obligations.  Now, when I think of not saving for retirement, I think of high school.

Do you love saving for retirement (is love too strong a word?) Do you hate it? How do you motivate yourself to save for something that is so abstract, and so far away?

Small Steps Will Lead To Lifestyle Change

I don’t look unhealthy from the outside, but I’ve never been good about exercise. Every New Year – even though I’ve stopped making New Year’s resolutions – I think, this will be the year I really get in shape. But I never sustained my efforts past a few days, because for some reason I saw “getting in shape” as this grand undertaking that requires me to run 5 miles a day, subsist on lettuce, reject beef, and swear off butter. FOREVER. And I’d try to do that, but after 3 days I am so sick and tired of salads and running, and that would be the end of that until the next year.

Now I understand why some people are so reluctant to save, or exercise – even though we know – we know! – it’s good for us. Because the big goals – Financial Independence, or Retirement, or Sailing Around The World, or Getting In Shape, can seem so far-off and impossible, or they seem to require an unrealistic level of discipline and structure. If you see route to Financial Independence as making your own toilet paper or buying clothes once every 10 years, then of course you couldn’t – and wouldn’t – do it.

This year, something clicked and my perspective on “getting in shape” changed. A few months ago, I seriously got into tango. It gave me some much needed exercise, but also made me realize that if I can’t dance for an hour without feeling exhausted, I really should kick my lifestyle from “sedentary” to “active”. Tango is such a joy – and it will be even more fun if I were in better shape and can dance for two hours straight (or maybe even 3! – imagine the possibilities!).

Then it’s as if a light bulb went off - life will be much more fun if I were in better shape. Just as personal finance shouldn’t make you miserable, a healthy lifestyle isn’t about deprivation. It’s not about saying “no” to delicious foods or relaxing days, it’s saying “yes” to taking good care of the only body you’ll ever have.

Some people spend beyond their means and don’t save for the future because they say, “you only live once”. But eventually, hopefully, they will realize that life will be much more fun if your finances were in order. If I am too unhealthy, I won’t enjoy my life, even if I can eat strawberry shortcakes every day. If I am too in debt and have creditors calling me every day, I won’t enjoy my life, even if I buy expensive cars or go on luxurious vacations.

A few days ago I took my first “small financial step” of 2010 – contributing $250 to my Roth IRA. On Monday, I will take my first (and very painful) “small exercise step” of 2010 – doing Day 1 of the 30 Day Shred. Small steps are worth celebrating, because if you maintain enough small steps, over a long enough period, you may be surprised to find yourself with a changed lifestyle, a changed outlook.

And the best part is, this lifestyle will be sustainable. Financial responsibility (or frugality, if you will), is not fad. Eating right and exercising are not fads. I know that now. And I’m willing to take enough small steps to make “getting in shape” happen.

What small steps have you taken to achieve your lifestyle goals?

(This is not a health or fitness blog, but I want to write more about this aspect of my life because there are so many parallels between fitness and finance, and they are both cornerstones of a healthy, happy life – how do you guys feel about that?)

Personal Finance Is Sexy

Recently CB opened a Roth IRA. Never doubt that personal finance knowledge is very attractive. (I wonder if my money nerdism has rubbed off on him).

I am so proud of him for taking this step. icon smile Personal Finance Is Sexy

So next time you are trying to interject some romance into your relationship, why not give your partner a card and say, “honey, I started saving for retirement!” Oh, the personal finance sparks will fly!

Personal Finance Blog Crush: The Recap

A week ago I did a little interesting post on all the crushin’ that’s going on in the world of personal finance blogs.

Apparently, many money-savvy girls are a little starry-eyed over J.Money of Budgets Are Sexy (not quite fair, I say – the name clearly sends a sublimal message!) and Debt Ninja of Punch Debt In The Face. Both guys, coincidentally, are in committed relationships. Sorry girls!

The other boys to be mentioned are Ramit of IWTYTBR, Clever Dude, Single Guy Money, and Frugal Bachelor.

On the ladies’ side, My Pretty Pennies, Krystal, Money Mate Kate, Stacking Pennies, Fabulously Broke, Squawk Fox, and many more have received blog crush designations from boys AND girls. Yet more proof that money-savvy people are hot comodities!

As for my blog crush, it has to be what I think of as the quintessential  personal finance blog and one of the first blogs I’ve started reading – Jonathan of MyMoneyBlog! (I also think his avatar is really cute). Let’s see if this mention can entice him over here and leave a comment. icon wink Personal Finance Blog Crush: The Recap

Let’s Play A Little Game Called “I have a Blog Crush on _______”

It’s summer time, and love’s in the air.

The whole thing started when RevancheGS and I were chatting, and I (somehow having momentarily regressed to 8th grade), asked her who her male PF Blog Crush is. And I thought it’d be funny to ask that question to, well, other people.

The “rules” are such:

1. Your PF Blog Crush can be any personal finance blog written by a member opposite sex (or, a member of the sex you are attracted to in real life).

2. Add a couple sentences (or more, if you really can’t hold back) on why you find that particular blog / blogger attractive. I.e.,  “The way he budgets just makes my knees go weak!” Or, “She sounds so exciting when she talks about the deal she got at the tire store.”

3. It doesn’t matter if that blogger is attached (it’s all just fun. No homewrecking on this blog, promise!).

4. You can be a blogger or a reader. You can comment anonymously if you’re shy.

5. Please send this to your friends / tweet (please use shortened url at moourl.com/blogcrush) – the more people who chimes in, the more fun it’ll be.

Next week, I’ll do a little summary post on all the crushin’ going on in the PF blogosphere.

And…. let the commenting begin! icon wink Lets Play A Little Game Called I have a Blog Crush on

When the Thrill of Blogging is Gone

The title of this post doesn’t refer to me (the thrill of personal finance? Gone? Nonsense!), but to the recently-published New York Times article on the fate of “orphan” blogs left by their owners.

I actually have “orphaned” several blogs. Some of them I don’t even remember the addresses – I had one at angelfire.com and another one at geocities.com and another one at scribble.nu (which doesn’t exist anymore). I also have a brief, public blog at livejournal.com. But eventually, after a couple of months, I left every one of those blogs orphans of the blogosphere!

When I first started Well-Heeled, it was conceived as a blog devoted to lifestyle, fashion, decor issues. My first post (long edited away) had pictures of an Anthropologie dress, that, at $400+, I had no business owning. Then I started reading now-defunct blogs such as FreeTheCow, NYCMoney, and Laws of Finance (anyone remember them?), and I thought it was really cool that people are taking charge of their financial lives, and writing for the world to see. It was as if I’ve suddenly developed a taste for something that I not only find interesting, but is also GOOD for me (loving personal finance is like loving brussel sprouts?).

What has helped me continue blogging at Well-Heeled is 1. a genuine interest in my topic (and the fact that I can still write about decor and shopping and everything else, after all, the trademark of a personal finance blogger is that one can write about money and, well, anything!) and 2. all the reader feedback I get. If I haven’t gotten any comments, I probably wouldn’t have continued blogging for as long as I have. I expect that at some point I’ll stop blogging, but for now, I can’t imagine when!

You Know You’re a Personal Finance Blogger When…

Here are ten easy ways to figure out if you are a personal finance blogger:

1. Whenever something happens, you think, “is this blog-worthy? And how do finances factor into it?”

2. You can write about the relationship between money and well, everything (for example, Sex and the City, Mother’s Day, weekend plans with boyfriend, and cheerleading).

3. You stop at buying just one pair of shoes because you know you will have to blog about it (a whole new outfit might be kind of difficult to explain to the pf blogosphere).

4. When pay day comes, your first reaction is: more money for investments & savings!

5. You write about personal finance in your personal journal and scrapbook economic news (wait, you mean that’s just me?)

6. It’s fun making up budgets for all sorts of different scenarios.

7. New articles keep harping on how young people don’t save, but you are worried about saving for retirement.

8. A big-time blogger comments on your post and it’s like a celebrity sighting. (Hi Jonathan!)

9. You love playing around with online personal finance calculators.

10. You don’t even remember what life was like before PF blog. (kidding! Sort of.)

Personal Finance Shouldn’t Make You Miserable

I don’t think personal finance is about deprivation. It’s really about making the choices that will support your highest priorities – the things or activities that will bring you the greatest joy or the deepest satisfaction.

Here is the newest Ask the Expert question from CNN Money

Question: I just turned 24, and the constant pressure from financial advisers to “save save save” for retirement makes me anxious that I’ll never be able to retire. I contribute 10% of my salary to my 401(k) each year – some of which my company matches – and I recently took on a second job to save for a home. Still, I feel miserable. My friends cruise around in BMWs, but I’m afraid to spend a dime on myself lest I ruin my future. I’ve looked at retirement calculators, but most don’t let you enter an age below 25. So I have no idea whether I’m doing enough, too much or just the right amount. What do you think? Are my worries are justified? —Jessica, Boston, Mass.

I read this question, and my first thought was… personal finance shouldn’t make you miserable. (My second thought? Spending money on yourself does NOT equal ruining your future. If that’s true, my road to cat-food retirement is paved with shoes, dresses, and lots and lots of food!)

I hope Jessica knows how well she is doing. She is saving for retirement, AND taking a second job to save even more. But I believe that if something makes you truly miserable (be it a job, a relationship, or a personal finance strategy), you won’t be very successful at it for very long, and that misery will likely poison other aspects of your life.

If your personal finance is making you miserable – some adjustments are in order:

(1) Expectations: If I expect to be driving a BMW at 23, living in a luxury high-rise, and dining at Spago every week, then yes, I might be pretty miserable in my current lifestyle, which includes none of those things. If I compared myself to friends who have a $100K trust fund set aside for them, that comparison probably won’t make me feel any better. In that case, I’d need to adjust my expectations to make sure that they aren’t making me miserable. Expecting to save 50% of your income on $40,000, while living in Manhattan is probably as unwise as expecting to dress head-to-toe in Chanel straight out of college.

(2) Savings rate: When I operated on a fairly strict budget trying to save 40%+ of my gross income every month, I wasn’t very happy and wasn’t very successful at all. Now that I’ve scaled back (and have pledged to make up part of the difference by saving all of my bonuses), I’m much more satisified with my lifestyle. This also means that instead of failing every month to achieve the 40% goal, I’m succeeding fabulously at saving almost a third of my income every month. This principle can be taken too far (how much more successful would I be if I just aimed to save 5% of my income?!). But if I am honest with myself, I know which goals will allow me to prepare for my future AND live well today, and which goals will make me miserable by neglecting quality of life today.

In conclusion? If you are reading this blog, know the importance of saving, and are doing something to prepare for your future? You are already doing well. Make sure that your personal finance reflects your personal situation and priorities, and please, personal finance should be a source of joy in your life (okay, that might be the PF blogger in me talking), not a source of misery and distress.

Reason #692314 I am a PF nerd

Tonight I went to Barnes & Noble to study.

During breaks between problem sets, I…

did NOT read Marie Claire or Real Simple or House Beautiful (all magazines I love)

did NOT flip through cook books with pages and pages of photos of delicious foods

did NOT dream about the latest in-style outfits in InStyle

did NOT catch up on Britney Spears’ latest news in US Weekly

did NOT follow the school rankings in US News

What did I do?

I browsed through personal finance and investing books.

Seriously.

Do I need help?